The above map shows some of my completed island mapping projects. Each icon contains the name of the primary island associated with the project and a link to the post. Once all of my projects are posted, the map will be covered with icons. To productively use the map, zoom into a region of interest. Then select an icon.

Each of my maps is constructed of numerous layers of information. All of the layers are vector files. I will make these files available upon request. You are free to use them with certain restrictions - 1) Don't sell them. You can use them on research projects, post them to your website or things of that nature. If you aren't sure about the use of my maps, drop me a line and we can discuss your idea. 2) Give me credit when you use my vectors or images of my maps. Credit them to Peter Minton @ EVS-Islands

If I have the island vector file(s) and based upon your need, I will make them available. Images of my maps are yours to download and use, with the above restrictions applicable. Enjoy!

Raster or Vector - Which Is Best?

Suwarrow Atoll (1-100000) I Select an Island To Work On
If you are going to digitize the outline of an island, you begin by selecting an island. This is an old project that I worked on previously.
Zoom I Typically Map At Zoom Level I Typically Digitize At (1:10,000)
I like to work at this zoom level (1:10,000). It alllows me to fine tune my digitizing. I feel my ability to accurately interpret the image data is solid at this level.
A Zoomed Raster Image Look At the Pixels! Why I Don't Work at 1:2,500
It would make sense that the closer I can get to my work the more accurate the digitizing would be. Not so! The above image clearly shows a key zoom problem - the individual pixels overpower the image they are intended to depict. Instead of seeing a picture of an island I see a picture of colored squares. If I didn't know I was working on an island shoreline, I could not guess what the underlying image was supposed to be. However, Global Mapper has an option that allows me to "interpolate" the underlying data, even at this scale.
Zoomed with Anti-Alias Pixels Turned On This is What Happens When You Anti-Alias Pixels (Interpolate)
The option is Anti-Alias Pixels (Interpolate). The process smooths the pixel edges and makes a "best guess" as to what those pixels are trying to show - an island shoreline with a vegetation layer. The point of this exercise is to demonstrate that raster images (pictures) when zoomed too far become a collage of colored squares - pixels. Some smart programs, like Global Mapper, created routines that attempt to overcome this weakness. The best type of map when working at these very close zoom levels is a vector map.
Zoomed Vector File Hyper-Zoomed Vector File (1:6 meters)
A vector file will show crisp clean lines at whatever scale you choose to work in. The one above is 1:6-meters. If you want a pretty map, work with pictures (raster images). If you want a practical map for a wide variety of applications and dynamic scales, work with vectors. OT: Special Topic

"Raster is faster, but Vector is smaller"

Something my old GIS teacher would say. Cool Islands :)

I don't hope you think you are achieving better accuracy by interpolation and zooming further in.
Experienced photogrammetry operators are able to achieve not much more than 1/3 of a pixel (for very well-defined objects), no matter what you do with interpolation (I would actually prefer not letting a black-box algorithm change my image!)
...and I wouldn't call a beach a well-defined object.

Post a Comment

Links to this post

Create a Link

2 Comments:

"Raster is faster, but Vector is smaller"

Something my old GIS teacher would say. Cool Islands :)

By Blogger Matt, at 4/27/2006 02:43:00 PM  

I don't hope you think you are achieving better accuracy by interpolation and zooming further in.
Experienced photogrammetry operators are able to achieve not much more than 1/3 of a pixel (for very well-defined objects), no matter what you do with interpolation (I would actually prefer not letting a black-box algorithm change my image!)
...and I wouldn't call a beach a well-defined object.

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/27/2006 03:31:00 PM  

Post a Comment

Powered by Blogger

E-mail Me

If You Enjoy My Maps,
Make A Donation


  • Google PageRank 
Checker - Page Rank Calculator

    About me

    • I'm Mr Minton
    • From San Diego, CA
    My profile

    Calendar


    Get your own calendar

    Software I Recommend

    Purchase Global Mapper v9

    Trial Download Global Mapper v9

    A moderately priced, easy-to-use GIS package, which I use to load, view and work with Landsat ETM+ imagery from which I digitize layers of information for my island maps.

    EVS Islands Projects

    EVS Islands RSS Feeds

    Subscribe to
    Posts [Atom]


    Google Reader or Homepage
    del.icio.us EVS-Islands
    Add to My Yahoo!
    Subscribe with Bloglines
    Subscribe in NewsGator Online
    myFeedster
    Add to My AOL
    Subscribe in Rojo

    Learn how to make RSS Feed Buttons

    Links

  • WVS Coastlines
  • Landsat-2000 ETM
  • Global Mapper
  • MARPLOT Mapping Program
  • NGA Prototype Global Shoreline
  • GEONet Names
  • NASA Earth



  • Creative Commons License

    This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 License
    .

    Locations of visitors to this page